Whats Their Chances? Part One: The Veterans

This is my new blog series where me and fellow gym bloggers: Bekah from getagripgymblog.blogspot.com andThe Girls From tripletwistgymblog.blogspot.com will talk about The USA contenders for London 2012.

This week were starting with the Olympic Veterans!

Alicia Sacramone

 Aoibhe From Flippin’ Olympics: Ah Alicia, why did you have to tear you achilles? WHY?

Before she tore her achilles at worlds, Alicia was considered a lock for London.  Shes a three event specialist (she doesn’t train bars) which holds her back a little bit. But, if Alicia gives a strong performance at Natonals and Trails, I wouldnt count her out.

Ashlee From Triple Twist BlogIf you would have asked me last year about Alicia’s chances I would have told you she was a lock for the team. But after tearing her achilles last year at Worlds, I don’t think its possible for her anymore. She would need to get in great shape AND upgrade her routines to be in the hunt for one of those 5 spots.

Bekah From Get A Grip Gymblog: To be honest, I was dubious about Alicia’s chances of making the Olympic team even prior to her injury. With McKayla Maroney possibly vying for vault gold, Alicia’s role from 2008 is occupied. She’s also without an Amanar, which seems almost necessary to compete on Vault in team finals for the USA. While Alicia would bring strong leadership skills to the team, I doubt that she’ll be able to reach Olympic shape AND upgrade before the Olympics.

Chellsie Memmel

AoibheShes not my favourite gymnast, but shes a like a rock! In the words of Tim And Elifie “This kid has mental toughness like no other” Who makes a comeback after 3 years and does what she did at nationals? Like it or not, shes a front runner for this team if she stays injury free.

Ashlee: As much as I wan’t to see Chellsie make the team, I don’t think she will. Her shoulder is has been giving her problems and she is only training lightly in the gym while she heals up. Chellsie is just too injured to give this a go!

Bekah: I adore Chellie Memmel but I worry if the girl who was too injured to go to the Olympics at 16 and was injured in Beijing at 20 will be able to stay healthy under Marta at 24. If she can somehow peak, the USA could use her bar set. I do have to give Chellsie credit though. She quietly arose last year and showed up at the US Classics in top form. She could surprise us all, and I hope she does, but this girl seems to have the worst timing of any gymnast on the planet

Bridget Sloan

AoibheThe 2009 world champion never really left the gymnastics scene like much of her teammates in Beijing  (she was on the 2009,2010 worlds team and 2011 Pan Am Captain.) but whats kinda sad is that even though she never left the scene for a while like the rest of her teammates and spent the last 4 years training yet she isint a ‘lock’ for this team. But even if she doesnt make this Olympic team, I hope she continues with gymnastics for as many years as she can!

AshleeBridget is good, but not good enough unfortunately. She has been dealing with some injury’s which have prevented her from competing at her full potential for almost 2 years. Her start values are not that high and she wouldn’t help the team out massively on any event.

BekahBridget Sloan has historically been consistent under pressure and solid on all four events. But that’s just it: she’s “just” solid. Frankly, I’m not sure if I’d place Bridget in the Top 5 girls in the US on any event. Barring injury, I think that Bridget has a solid shot as being an alternate. But without 4 or 5 major players going down, I’m unsure if I can realistically see Bridget on this team.


 Shawn Johnson

Aoibhedont get me wrong here, I love Shawn and i think she is a wonderful gymnast. but i think she had her day. I don’t really see a place for her in this team, when theres only 5 places and loads of girls fighting for it. I think she’ll be an alternate. but she should be happy with that, considering the the depth of talent in the USA right now.

AshleeOh I want Shawn to make this team so bad! She’s in the right position, she just needs to keep training and get consistent at her routines. She only has a few meets coming up to prove herself, but it sounds like she has some upgrades that could help her chances. It will be tough, but it is possible.

BekahI have to commend Shawn for coming back, but I worry that her shaky performances in 2011 will work against her. Perhaps her great reputation and strong performance at the US Championships will make up for her performances at Classics and Pan Ams. Shawn could realistically compete for the US on beam and floor, where they more than likely will not need a specialist. All in all, I think that if Shawn can stay healthy, she will more than likely be an alternate.

Nastia Liukin

AoibheNastia can swing bars. And lets face it, USA cant swing bars as good as we’d like.And being the olympic All-Around Champion cant hurt either.We still haven’t seen any of Nastia’s comeback yet, but you can nearly be garanteed her bars will bring in big scores.

Ashlee: For some reason, I only see Nastia being useful on bars. (Which we need!) I’m pretty positive she will make the team though. After all she has done for USA Gymnastics, I can’t imagine her not making it. I mean come on, she’s an Olympic Champion! She has a huge bar set that will be very helpful to the team score and overall I think she’d make a great leader to a much younger team.

BekahI’d like to remind you of a deep dark year in American Gymnastics: 2000. Veterans Kim Zmeskal, Dominique Moceanu, Jaycie Phelps and Shannon Miller all attempted comebacks and didn’t make the team. Why? They jumped in the ring at the last minute, much like Nastia. Honestly, I HOPE Nastia can make a comeback and can peak at the right time. We NEED her bars. However, I’m not sure I’ll believe it until I see it.

PLEASE LEAVE YOUR COMMENTS!

Coming next week in Part 2 of ‘Whats Their Chances?’ We’ll be looking at the chances of the 2011 Gold Winning World Championship Team!

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Whats Their Chances? Part One: The Veterans

  1. I’d be interested to hear everyone’s opinions on Shawn’s bars. They’ve always been very clean and well-executed, just overshadowed by the difficulty of others.’ We’ve also seen some bar upgrades from her over the last year. What if she rocks bars at Classics, Visas, and Trials? Maybe they could use her! Without Nastia, bars could end up being Gabby, Kyla, and Jordyn, and I really think Shawn could prove more consistent on bars than Jo. I don’t think any of us can make a judgement on how much Nastia could help us with bars until we actually see what the heck she has been doing in secret since the Fall. What do you guys think?

    • Yes, I’m very suspicious of Nastias Bars – I’m sure they’ll be wonderful – but will they be enough to get her on the team? Gabby Douglas and Jo really have the bars gap filled but Possibly Bross or Kyla could be the other bar worker. (Depending on who makes the team) but in qualification they’ll probably have to use Raisman on bars. Or possible Maroney.
      I’m still not so sure about Shawns comeback. She would need to have a steller performance at trails. Finish in the top 5 in all events probably. But for now, I’m not so sure.

  2. As much as I’d love to see Alicia Sacramone on the team (I think her experience and leadership could really help lead the US Team) I think Mckayla Maroney fills her need on vault. I would be a little surprised if Nastia or Shawn made the team, but the US does need a strong bars workers (Nastia!). I’m excited for the next post!

  3. I love this! This is the first honest look at the 2008 team making comebacks in my opinion. While I love all the girls and their gymnastics I think it is time that more people sit back and think about their chances realistically, it’s not about what they have done for the sport it’s about what they will be able to do in London. Awesome job!

Whats your opinion?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s